Constitutional Court Upholds Gradual Harmonisation of Supplementary Pensions
Category: Employment & Benefits
Traditionally, Belgian labour law distinguished between employment terms for blue-collar workers (primarily engaged in manual labor) and white-collar employees (primarily performing administrative tasks). However, the legislator has been actively pursuing measures to achieve greater harmonisation between these two categories of workers.
A key focus of this harmonisation effort is the alignment of supplementary pension schemes for blue-collar and white-collar employees. The Constitutional Court recently issued a significant decision that supports the legal framework established in the Supplementary Pensions Act (SPA), which outlines a phased approach to gradually reconcile these categories.
This approach allows for a systematic and measured integration of employment rights and benefits, recognising the historical differences while working towards a more equitable workplace framework
I. Background
The harmonisation of supplementary pensions for blue-collar and white-collar employees is progressing gradually under Belgian law. Initially, the elimination of differences was scheduled for 1 January 2025, however, this deadline was later extended to 1 January 2030. After this date, any distinction in supplementary pensions between blue-collar and white-collar employees in comparable situations will be considered discriminatory.
The SPA provides for three phases to gradually achieve harmonisation by 1 January 2030:
Prior to 1 January 2015 (N1 period): Existing differences are considered non-discriminatory;
1 January 2015 – 31 December 2029 (N2 period): A transition period where existing differences may continue (subject to certain conditions), but new distinctions are prohibited. Existing differences cannot be widened unless they contribute to equal treatment; and
From 1 January 2030 (N3 period): All differences in supplementary pensions between blue-collar and white-collar employees in comparable situations will be considered discriminatory.
II. Supplementary Pension discussion before Labour Court
A blue-collar worker who was employed by a public transport operator and retired on 1 June 2015 disputed his supplementary pension amount before the Brussels Labor Court (judgement dated 16 October 2023). He claimed that the plan discriminated between blue-collar and white-collar employees as only part of the year-end premium (“13th month”) was considered for the reference salary for pension calculation for blue-collar workers, whereas the full amount was included for white-collar employees.
The Labour Court acknowledged that there was indeed a difference in pension calculation. However, the Labour Court stated that it could not assess its constitutionality since the SPA tolerated such distinctions provided that they were established prior to 1 January 2015 (see phases N1 and N2 above). The blue-collar worker subsequently requested the Labour Court to submit two questions to the Constitutional Court regarding the matter:
III. 2 questions submitted to the Constitutional Court
In the first question, the Labour Court asked the Constitutional Court to clarify whether articles 14/1 to 14/4 of the SPA (which contain the three phases toward harmonisation outlined in I.) violate the equality and non-discrimination principles (Articles 10-11 Belgian Constitution). It also inquires whether these articles of the SPA violate the right to a dignified life, which includes, among other things, the right to social security (Article 23 Constitution) insofar as they prevent a worker who has a pension entitlement containing discrimination based on the blue-collar/white-collar distinction from challenging this discrimination.
The Constitutional Court confirms that there is no violation of constitutional equality principles. The legislator has the right to change measures and pursue different goals, and this in itself does not amount to discrimination.
Also, the Constitutional Court endorses the legislator's decision in the light of article 23 of the Constitution to avoid abrupt changes that may destabilise the supplementary pension system, opting instead for gradual reforms to harmonise supplementary pensions between blue-collar and white-collar employees. This approach helps prevent legal uncertainty and economic difficulties, according to the Constitutional Court.
The second preliminary question asks the Constitutional Court whether the provisions of the SPA regarding the phased harmonisation violate Articles 10-11 of the Constitution, in conjunction with Article 14 of the ECHR and Article 1 of the First Additional Protocol to the ECHR (right to property), insofar as they prevent employees from challenging discrimination in pension schemes based on the blue-collar/white-collar distinction, while employees can still challenge discrimination based on other criteria. Here as well, the Constitutional Court found there was no violation of equality principles nor of the right to property.
Key Takeaway
|