Employers' Right to Hire Private Detectives to Gather Evidence for Termination for Cause
Category: Employment & Benefits
The Brussels Labour Court recently confirmed the right of employers to hire private detectives to gather evidence for a termination for cause. In the case at hand, the employer contracted a private detective to obtain evidence that the employee was engaging in competing activities (while on sick leave). The Court highlighted in its decision that for the evidence gathered by private detectives to be considered valid, both the specific professional regulations applicable to private detectives and data protection legislation must be observed.
I. Termination for cause: key points
Termination for cause (Dutch: dringende reden/French: motif grave) refers to a termination of employment without observance of a notice period or payment in lieu of notice. Employers may only terminate for cause if the employee’s fault is of such severity that it makes continuing the employment relationship immediately and permanently impossible. Also, termination for cause is subject to strict formalities in terms of timing and termination documentation.
In case employees successfully challenge a termination for cause, the employer may be condemned to pay a payment in lieu to the employee, along with other potential termination indemnities. It is therefore key for employers to obtain sufficient evidence of the reasons for termination. The types of evidence that can be used to justify the reasons for termination are diverse and may even include material gathered by a private detective provided that certain conditions are met.
II. Context of the caSE
The employer was active in the construction sector, specialising in heating systems and plumbing. The employee in question was repeatedly on sick leave. Although his work incapacity was supported by medical certificates, the employer suspected that he was working (as a competitor) during his sick leave because the company discovered a website where the worker was offering plumbing services during the company’s working hours. The employer hired a private detective, whose findings confirmed these suspicions (e.g., via photos on which the employee was seen working on a construction site). Based on the evidence gathered by the private detective, the employer terminated the employee for cause, without notice or payment in lieu.
III. Summary of the Court’s decision
The employee challenged his termination for cause, first before the Brussels Labour Tribunal and on appeal before the Brussels Labour Court (French-speaking section) and claimed a payment in lieu, among other claims. One of the main arguments he presented was that the courts should disregard the report of the private detective because it violated the applicable regulations; however, the Court however rebutted his claims:
- Photographs in a non-public area: The private detective took photos of the employee’s vehicle while it was parked near his home on private property. Nevertheless, the Court found that these photos were taken in an area that is accessible to the public and therefore complied with the regulations applicable to private detectives’ duties.
- Disclosure of irrelevant information: The detective followed the employee while he was dropping off his child at a daycare facility in his commercial vehicle. The employee asserted that this information was irrelevant to the investigation and should not have been shared with his employer. However, the Court disagreed and stated that the detective was investigating the employee’s professional activities and any use of the commercial vehicle was therefore relevant. Also, the detective was legally required to report everything he observed, even if it was not directly related to the professional activity.
- Collection of health data: The employee argued that the detective was given the instructions to collect information about his health, which is prohibited by the regulations governing private detectives’ duties. However, the Court found that the employer had only assigned the private detective to investigate the employee’s (competing) professional activities and not his health status.
The court concluded that the report issued by the private detective complied with both the specific regulations applicable to the profession as well as with data protection legislation. Therefore, the employer was entitled to terminate the employee for cause based on the findings in this report.
III. Key take aways
Employers can hire private detectives for evidence gathering (in dismissal cases). This can indeed be useful for cases where evidence is not easy to obtain, e.g., competing activities or conflicts of interest. Strict compliance with regulations regarding the profession of private detectives and data protection is however essential to build a case that will hold up in court if the termination for cause is challenged.