Federal Circular regarding post-employment conflict of interests and its relation to public procurement
Category: Regulatory
On 13 June 2024, Federal Circular No 735 was published in the Belgian Official Gazette regarding an "Overview of measures to prevent post-employment conflicts of interest (revolving door constructions) in the federal administrative civil service". The circular aims to clarify the nature of post-employment conflicts of interest that may arise, among former federal civil servants. In this respect, it gives an overview of existing legal measures to prevent such conflicts and to pursue a preventive policy. The circular includes some aspects relating to public procurement which will be explained below.
Post-employment conflict of interest: what’s in a name?
A post-employment conflict of interest is defined in the circular as “a situation in which, after a staff member's employment has been formally terminated, personal, private and/or organisational interests conflict with the representation of the public interest, and where there is a risk that these personal, private and/or organisational interests may improperly and non-legitimately influence the representation of the public interest because former staff members may make use of knowledge, information, skills and contacts accumulated with the former employer” (free translation of the circular). Consequently, it concerns a risk of entanglement of interests, where there is a non-legitimate influence of the public interest by a personal, private or organisational interest and thus a possible integrity violation.
Examples include the use or misuse of confidential (file) knowledge or knowledge about systems, procedures and working methods. This knowledge can be misused, for example, to give a new employer an unfair advantage in a government contract. The use of former colleagues to influence them in a government contract or in the determination of its needs are also type examples of such conflicts.
As a result, public procurement is one of the areas in which there is a higher risk of post-employment conflicts of interest and potential entanglement of interest.
Measures to prevent post-employment conflicts of interest
Several measures can be taken to prevent post-employment conflicts of interest. Within public procurement in traditional sectors, for example, a ‘cooling-off period’ applies. This means that for two years after leaving employment, former staff members of the contracting authority are prohibited from intervening in activities related to a public contract. This includes preparing the tender, submitting the application, participating in negotiations, as well as executing the contract. Evidently, this ‘cooling off period’ only applies in the event that there is a link between the former activities and the activities related to the public contract. After two years, the link with the former employer is considered to be less strong, so a cooperation with a former colleague no longer constitutes a conflict of interest.
Public procurement in the special sectors is not subject to this cooling-off period. This would, in fact, be detrimental to the labour mobility of staff in public enterprises.
In addition, for specific positions in the federal government, there is a temporary ban on transferring to a particular position in the private sector. The duty of confidentiality for civil servants, as provided for in the Royal Decree of 2 October 1937, can also serve as a measure to prevent a conflict of interest after leaving employment.
Post-employment disclosure of conflicts of interest
Pursuant to Article 6 §1 of the Public Procurement Act, the contracting authority must take the necessary measures to effectively prevent, identify and resolve conflicts of interest both during the placing and the execution of the public contract. In this way, distortion of competition must be avoided and equal treatment of all economic operators must be ensured. This applies specifically to persons involved in decisions on the award and supervision of the execution of public contracts.
The federal circular also brings to mind the circular already published in 2010. Based on this circular, those involved in a public contract must make a written declaration “for each individual public contract for which they consider themselves to be in a potential state of conflict of interest” (free translation of the circular). This declaration is to sensitise potential conflicts of interest and is required in the case of tasks involving a "power of judgment" or "knowledge of confidential data". In purely executive tasks, this declaration is thus not required.
The written declaration must be communicated to the person's superior and the contracting authority. If there is then an effective conflict of interest, the staff member must recuse himself.
Possible sanctions
Conflict of interest in the context of public procurement leads to distortion of competition and is sanctioned (subject to some exceptions) by the rejection of the tender or termination of the contract.
A preventive policy?
One of the measures the circular mentions as part of a preventive policy is to conduct a risk analysis. A risk analysis includes an inventory of vulnerable functions and tasks. The Federal Public Service Policy and Support (“FOD BOSA”) can provide coordination and support.
In the context of public procurement, such risk analysis can be carried out with a view to understanding (potential) conflicts of interest among buyers.
Do not hesitate to contact our Regulatory team with any questions regarding (potential) conflicts of interest within public procurement.