Back to home

Fishing expeditions under belgian law: a fine line between legal and illegal

Category: IP/IT/Data

shutterstock_2507692995

It goes without saying that companies wish to protect their business-critical information against competitors. Belgian law provides for ex parte proceedings enabling a company to conduct (protective and/or seizure) investigations at the competitor’s premises without warning. For example, ex parte counterfeiting seizure proceedings can allow descriptive and/or seizure measures with respect to copyright, trademark rights, patent rights and/or design rights, whilst unilateral summary proceedings can be initiated to obtain protective measures for trade secrets. However, there is a fine line between legal evidentiary expeditions and illegal fishing expeditions.

The Antwerp court of appeal (“court”) rendered a decision on 28 June 2023 in which a request for ex parte counterfeiting descriptive measures based on an alleged copyright infringement was denied because the request did not pursue the intended objectives of the proceedings, but instead involved a prohibited fishing expedition and, therefore, an abuse of rights.

Further to this decision, the following do’s and don’ts are worth keeping in mind when walking said fine line, either as plaintiff or as defendant:

Icon brain settings

Choose your rights wisely:

The invoked rights determine the type of proceedings that could be initiated. Therefore, it should be carefully ascertained which proceedings will be initiated based on which rights. It is also possible to initiate different proceedings based on a combination of rights, e.g. ex parte counterfeiting seizure proceedings based on copyrights and unilateral summary proceedings based on trade secrets.

Icon clock

Time is of the essence:

Extreme urgency is required within the framework of unilateral summary proceedings, whereas ex parte counterfeiting seizure proceedings do not include a time-related precondition. Nonetheless, the court took into account the time lapse between the start date of the alleged infringement and the filing of the request within the framework of its assessment of abuse of rights.

Thus, as a general guideline, a plaintiff is expected to act in a timely manner after gaining knowledge of the alleged (threat of) infringement. If not, the defendant can raise the time lapse as an argument when appealing the imposed measures.

Icon checklist

Evidence is key:

Although ex parte proceedings only require proof of a seemingly valid right and an apparent infringement, the plaintiff still has to meet its burden of proof. While the court accepted that this burden of proof was met, the first judge (whose decision was appealed before the court) denied the request because the plaintiff failed to prove the existence of a seemingly valid right.

Even though the purpose of ex parte proceedings is to gather or secure evidence, the plaintiff must still produce evidence of its allegations. Taking into account the time constraint, it is important to create a record in advance, especially for non-registered rights such as copyright and trade secret protection. E.g. as to the condition of a seemingly valid right, such record can include the existence, scope and ownership of the invoked right, confidentiality clauses with respect to trade secrets, technical security measures to keep trade secrets confidential, IP transfer clauses to prove copyright ownership, etc. Furthermore, an estimation of the value of the rights can be included in the accounts to facilitate valuation during proceedings particularly for damages.

Icon scale

Do not go beyond what is necessary:

The court mainly condemned the scope of the requested measures. The court ruled that the requested measures were too far-reaching and that less intrusive measures existed to obtain the desired result.

It is therefore advisable to carefully delineate the requested measures to what is strictly necessary. Abstain from overly general measures with a wide scope to avoid a qualification as fishing expedition.

Please do not hesitate to reach out to one of the members of the IP/IT/Data team of Liedekerke on their individual e-mail address or via ip-team@liedekerke.com in case of questions regarding ex parte proceedings.

Back to overview