It goes without saying that companies wish to protect their business-critical information against competitors. Belgian law provides for ex parte proceedings enabling a company to conduct (protective and/or seizure) investigations at the competitor’s premises without warning. For example, ex parte counterfeiting seizure proceedings can allow descriptive and/or seizure measures with respect to copyright, trademark rights, patent rights and/or design rights, whilst unilateral summary proceedings can be initiated to obtain protective measures for trade secrets. However, there is a fine line between legal evidentiary expeditions and illegal fishing expeditions.
The Antwerp court of appeal (“court”) rendered a decision on 28 June 2023 in which a request for ex parte counterfeiting descriptive measures based on an alleged copyright infringement was denied because the request did not pursue the intended objectives of the proceedings, but instead involved a prohibited fishing expedition and, therefore, an abuse of rights.
Further to this decision, the following do’s and don’ts are worth keeping in mind when walking said fine line, either as plaintiff or as defendant: