Back to home

The Court of Justice clarifies the conditions to obtain compensation for non-material damages under the GDPR

Category: IP/IT/Data

Quite a few cases have been brought before the CJEU regarding the interpretation of article 82 GDPR, granting individuals the right to seek compensation for both material and non-material damages suffered as a consequence of GDPR infringements. In particular the conditions to obtain compensation for ‘non-material’ damages has been further clarified by the CJEU.

The findings of the CJEU can be summarised as follows:

  • for a compensation for non-material damages to be granted the following three criteria should be cumulatively met: (i) a violation of the GDPR, (ii) the existence of actual damage, and (iii) a causal link between the violation and the damage;

  • the mere fear experienced by a data subject with regard to a possible future misuse of his or her personal that was compromised in a personal data breach can constitute non-material damage;

  • only damage concretely suffered as a result of the breach of the GDPR can be compensated;

  • the GDPR does not require that, the ‘non-material damage’ alleged by the data subject must reach a ‘de minimis threshold’ or degree of seriousness;

  • the gravity of the breach of the GDPR and the fact that several infringements occurred regarding the same processing activity should not be taken into account when calculating the amount of compensation for non-material damage;

  • the criteria for setting the amount of administrative fines laid down in article 83 GDPR should not be taken into account when calculating the amount of compensation for non-material damage.

In this legal insight, we give an overview of the relevant facts and findings of the CJEU’s recent case law regarding non-material damages.

For more information on this topic, please contact our IP, IT and data protection team by sending an e-mail to IP/IT-team@liedekerke.com.

The Court of Justice clarifies the conditions to obtain compensation for non-material damages under the GDPR

In our legal insight of 17 January 2024 (to be consulted here), we discussed two cases of the Court of Justice of the European Union (“CJEU”) regarding the interpretation of article 83 GDPR, clarifying the conditions for administrative fines to be imposed on controllers for GDPR infringements.

Quite a few cases have also been brought before the CJEU regarding the interpretation of article 82 GDPR, granting individuals the right to seek compensation for both material and non-material damages suffered as a consequence of GDPR infringements. In particular the conditions to obtain compensation for ‘non-material’ damages has been further clarified by the CJEU in the following (landmark) cases, which are discussed briefly below:

Some of these cases also cover preliminary questions regarding other topics under the GDPR. The overview however is limited to the relevant facts and main findings regarding the compensation for non-material damages.

1.Österreichische Post

Facts: The case concerned the practices of a data broker collecting information on the political affinities of the Austrian population, with a view of defining ‘target group addresses’ using an algorithm that would take into account various social and demographic criteria. The data thus generated were sold to various organisations, to enable them to send targeted advertising. In the course of its activity, the data broker processed data which led it to infer that the applicant had a high degree of affinity with a certain Austrian political party. That information was not communicated to third parties, but the applicant felt offended by the fact that an affinity with the party in question had been attributed to him, which (allegedly) caused him great upset, a loss of confidence and a feeling of exposure for which he claimed non-material damages.

CJEU:

Compensation for non-material damage may not be subject to the condition that the damage suffered by the data subject has reached a certain degree of seriousness. For non-material damages to be granted, three conditions must be cumulatively met. There must be: (i) a violation of the GDPR, (ii) the existence of actual damage, and (iii) a causal link between the violation and the damage. As the GDPR contains no provision aimed at establishing the rules for calculating the compensation due under the right to damages enshrined in article 82, national courts must, to that end, by virtue of the principle of procedural autonomy, apply each Member State's internal rules on the extent of monetary compensation.

2.VB v Natsionalna agentsia za prihodite

Facts: A Bulgarian authority suffered a personal data breach compromising the personal data of more than 6 million natural persons whose personal data was published online. Several hundred of them, including the appellant, brought actions against the authority for compensation for non-material damage allegedly resulting from the disclosure of their personal data. The data subject’s alleged non-material damage consisted in the fear that her personal data, having been published without her consent, might be misused in the future, or that she herself might be blackmailed, assaulted or even kidnapped

CJEU:

The mere fear experienced by a data subject with regard to a possible future misuse of his or her personal that was compromised in a personal data breach can constitute non-material damage under the GDPR, even if there is no evidence that any such misuse has actually occurred. However, a data subject will only be able to claim such compensation if he or she can prove that he or she has in fact suffered such damage as a result of the breach, meaning he or she can demonstrate the existence of a well-founded fear of future misuse, and that there is a causal link between such damage and the GDPR infringement.

3.Gemeinde Ummendorf

Facts: Without the consent of the applicants, a municipality in Germany published on the internet the agenda of a meeting of the municipal council, in which their names were referred to on several occasions. The applicants claimed that the mere publication caused them non-material damage and claimed compensation for it.

CJEU:

CJEU: The GDPR does not require that the ‘non-material damage’ alleged by the data subject must reach a ‘de minimis threshold’ in order for that damage to be capable of compensation. A data subject concerned by an infringement of the GDPR which has negative consequences for him or her is, however, required to demonstrate that those consequences constitute non-material damage within the meaning of article 82 GDPR (hence demonstrate actual damages suffered). The mere infringement of the GDPR is not sufficient to confer a right to compensation.

4.Krankenversicherung Nordrhein

Facts: The case concerned an IT employee of a company conducting assessments of individual’s incapability of work for insurance companies. The employee himself fell ill and in the context of his absence, his insurance company requested his employer to conduct such an assessment of the employee concerned. In essence, the applicant argued that the expert opinion drafted by his employer should have been carried out by another medical department, to avoid his colleagues having access to his medical data, and that the security measures surrounding the archiving of the report were inadequate. He also claimed that this processing constituted a violation of the legal rules regarding the processing of health related data, which had caused him both moral and material damage.

CJEU:  

The gravity of the breach of the GDPR should not be taken into account when calculating the amount of compensation for non-material damage to be awarded. The amount should be determined in such a way as to compensate in full for the damage concretely suffered as a result of the breach of the GDPR.

5.MediaMarktSaturn

Facts: The applicant’s contractual paper documents concerning his purchase at Saturn, holding his personal data (including bank details and salary as the applicant made his purchase on credit), were erroneously provided to another customer by a Saturn employee but immediately thereafter - within 30 minutes - retrieved from such other customer and provided to the applicant. The applicant claimed to have suffered non-material damages and requested Saturn for compensation.

CJEU:

The concept of ‘non-material damage’ encompasses a situation in which the data subject experiences the well-founded fear that some of his or her personal data may be subject to dissemination or misuse by third parties in the future, on account of the fact that a document containing those data was provided to an unauthorised third party who was afforded the opportunity to take copies before returning it. However, the applicant should demonstrate the existence of such damage. A purely hypothetical risk of misuse by an unauthorised third party cannot give rise to compensation, which is the case if no third party became aware of the personal data at issue.

6.GP v juris

Facts: Juris, a provider of legal research services, kept sending the applicant direct marketing messages albeit the fact that the latter revoked, in writing, all his consents to receive information from Juris by e-mail or by telephone, and that he objected to any processing of his personal data for direct marketing purposes, except for the purposes of sending newsletters which he wished to continue to receive. The applicant claimed that he had suffered a loss of control over his personal data as a result of the processing of those data by juris despite his objections, and that he therefore was entitled to obtain compensation.

CJEU:

In order to determine the amount of damages due as compensation for damage based on article 82 GDPR, it is not necessary, first, to apply mutatis mutandis the criteria for setting the amount of administrative fines laid down in article 83 GDPR and, second, to take into account that several infringements of that regulation concerning the same processing operation affect the person seeking compensation.

Back to overview