In 2015, FIFA enacted a ban on Third-Party Ownership (TPO) – agreements whereby investors other than the player or their club could hold stakes in transfer fees.
That same year, R.F.C. Seraing, a Belgian football club, entered TPO agreements with a finance company (Doyen Sports), prompting FIFA to impose a player registration ban and a fine. These sanctions were largely upheld by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS), which has jurisdiction to hear appeals against final decisions passed by FIFA and its bodies pursuant to the FIFA Statutes. Since the CAS is an arbitral tribunal with its seat in Switzerland, a petition for annulment of the CAS award was submitted to the Swiss Federal Tribunal which rejected the petition.
As a court of a non-EU Member State, the Swiss Federal Tribunal cannot request a preliminary ruling from the ECJ on matters of general EU law. In parallel, R.F.C. Seraing therefore brought proceedings against FIFA before the Belgian Courts, seeking a ruling that the ban on TPO was incompatible with fundamental EU law principles, including the rights of free movement of capital, freedom of movement of workers and freedom to provide services.
The Brussels Court of Appeal rejected the claim, holding that R.F.C. Seraing’s arguments had already been raised and rejected by the CAS, and that the CAS award – once upheld by the Swiss Federal Tribunal – had res judicata effect (meaning it was final and binding). In other words, the Belgian Court considered the dispute with FIFA definitively resolved, with no possibility of reopening or further judicial review.
R.F.C. Seraing then appealed to the Belgian Court of Cassation, which referred a question to the ECJ for a preliminary ruling (explained below).