10 years’ Anniversary of CBA no. 109 in 10 Burning Questions on Dismissal Motivation
Category: Employment & Benefits
Estimated reading time: 10 minutes
In 2014, collective bargaining agreement no. 109 (CBA no. 109) introduced a unified regime on the motivation of dismissals for blue- and white-collar employees. Since then, dismissed employees have the right to know the concrete reasons which have led to their termination. If the dismissal is held to be “patently unreasonable”, employees can claim damages up to 17 weeks’ remuneration.
A dismissal is considered patently unreasonable if it (i) is unrelated to the employee’s performance or behaviour, or to the operational requirements of the undertaking, and (ii) would never have been decided by a normal and reasonable employer.
As we mark the 10th anniversary of CBA no. 109, it’s the perfect time to reflect on its impact on the motivation of dismissals in Belgium.
Over the past decade, many employers have faced requests from and/or litigations with former employees based on CBA no. 109. This led to a substantial body of case-law with important clarifications and, at times, controversies.
Below, we address 10 Burning Questions about CBA no. 109 based on key case-law decisions.
1. Are employees with less than 6 months’ seniority excluded from the scope of CBA no. 109?
Pursuant to Article 2, §2 of CBA no. 109, employees dismissed during the first 6 months of employment do not fall under its scope of application.
Despite its clarity, this provision has led to divergent decisions by the labour courts.
The Labour Court of Brussels ruled that this provision amounts to discrimination between employees with less than 6 months’ service and other employees. As a result, the court set aside this provision and applied CBA no. 109 to the dismissal of an employee with only 5 months’ service (French Labour Court of Brussels, 3 September 2020).
On the other hand, the vast majority of courts have rejected the argument of discrimination and refused to apply CBA no. 109 to employees with less than 6 months’ service (Labour Court of Liège (Neufchâteau), 12 July 2022; Labour Court of Liège (Marche-en-Famenne), 10 August 2022; Labour Court of Liège (Liège), 15 November 2022).
Key Takeaway:This controversy creates uncertainty for employers dismissing employees during their first 6 months of employment. A prudent approach for employers is therefore to provide employees dismissed during their first 6 months of employment with a motivation of their termination, if they so request, while stressing that the company reserves all rights to challenge the applicability of CBA no. 109 to their dismissal. |
2. How detailed must the employer’s dismissal motivation be?
The employer has the possibility to spontaneously provide the employee with the ‘concrete reason(s)’ for his/her dismissal. Failing a spontaneous motivation, if the employee sends a (valid) request for motivation, the employer has the obligation to respond (i) by registered letter (ii) within 2 months after receipt of the request (iii) by providing the employee with (an overview of) the ‘concrete reasons’ for his/her dismissal. If any of these conditions is not met, the employer owes a lump-sum civil fine of 2 weeks’ remuneration.
In particular, the concept of ‘concrete reasons’ has sparked numerous debates before the labour courts.
It is now settled case-law that general, stereotypical or vague reasons (such as the mere mention of “reorganisation” or “no longer suited for the function”) do not pass the test.
Courts have consistently emphasized that the reasons for termination must be detailed enough to allow the employees to understand the specific grounds that led to their dismissal. However, some courts have, rightly in our view, accepted brief, not very detailed and/or not very circumstantiated reasons, as long as they refer to factual and tangible elements (Labour Appeal Court of Liège, 12 December 2023). This is in accordance with the spirit of CBA no. 109, which only requires employers to provide an ‘overview’ of the reasons for termination.
For instance, the following reasons have been considered as sufficiently concrete:
“You have failed to perform the tasks inherent to your position both in terms of economic and educational objectives” (Labour Appeal Court of Liège, 12 December 2023); and
“taking into account the difficulties encountered, a restructuring has been carried out resulting in the removal of your role” (French Labour Court of Brussels, 7 December 2016).
But some courts are more severe, as reflected in a decision of January 2024 ordering the employer to pay the 2 weeks’ civil fine for having communicated the following reasons for termination: “The reason for your termination was explained to you last Friday. In particular, there has been a breach of trust between you and the company's management, based not only on your work, but also on external factors such as negative comments about the company in public and with customers. Secondly, we are in the process of restructuring to face the future of our company as part of a wider Group.” (Labour Court of Liège, 12 January 2024).
Key Takeaway:Hence, the key takeaway for employers should be to back up the reason(s) for termination with tangible facts and to describe them in a sufficiently concrete and precise manner to enable the employees to understand the reasons for their dismissal. |
3. Can the employer use the unemployment certificate as spontaneous motivation of the dismissal?
There is still controversy regarding the possibility to rely on the so-called ‘C4 form’ (i.e., the mandatory unemployment certificate to be provided to employees upon termination and which must briefly state the reason for termination) to consider that the employer has spontaneously provided the employee with the concrete reasons for termination. If so, the employer would be released from the obligation to respond to an employee’s request for motivation.
For the Labour Court of Mons, nothing prevents employers from using the C4 form as a spontaneous motivation, provided that the reasons mentioned on the form are sufficiently concrete (Labour Court of Mons, 11 May 2021).
For the Labour Appeal Court of Brussels, the C4 form can never be used as a spontaneous motivation of the dismissal because it derives from a legal obligation and is intended for the National Employment Office (Labour Appeal Court of Brussels, 17 April 2024).
We therefore strongly recommend, in the current state of the case-law, not to rely (solely) on the C4 form to spontaneously provide employees with the concrete reasons for their dismissal. As the case may be, such motivation can be included in the termination letter or any other written form.
Key Takeaway:We therefore strongly recommend, in the current state of the case-law, not to rely (solely) on the C4 form to spontaneously provide employees with the concrete reasons for their dismissal. As the case may be, such motivation can be included in the termination letter or any other written form. |
4. Can the employer change the reasons for termination afterwards?
Some employers tend to mention a ‘soft’ or vague reason for termination on the C4-form, then to provide different or more serious reasons in the motivation letter sent to the employee on his/her request, and eventually to rely on (additional) new reasons in the course of legal proceedings.
In light of the case-law to date, employers should avoid such practices. Rather, the reasons for termination should, as much as possible, remain unchanged and only be clarified at the employee’s request or in the context of the legal proceedings.
Successive reasons, late explanations or raised on a subsidiary basis, may be regarded as suspicious, inconsistent and/or unreliable (Labour Appeal Court of Brussels, 26 March 2018).
5. How do courts assess the ‘patently unreasonable’ character of a dismissal?
A dismissal will only entitle the employee to claim damages under CBA no. 109 if it is considered ‘patently unreasonable’ or, in other words, if the reasons for termination are very unfair.
Pursuant to established case-law, there are four key stages in the judicial review of the dismissal motivation:
Legality Check: the court first examines whether the reason(s) for termination given by the employer fit(s) within one (or more) of the three categories of legitimate reasons defined by CBA no. 109, i.e. (i) the employee’s performance and/or (ii) behaviour, and/or (iii) the operational requirements of the undertaking;
Reality Check: the court then verifies the accuracy of the reasons for termination, i.e. whether they are sufficiently documented ;
Causality Check: next, the court assesses whether the alleged concrete reasons are the real cause of the dismissal;
Proportionality Check: finally, the court verifies whether the dismissal would (never) have been decided by a normal and reasonable employer.
Courts apply a strict scrutiny (or full review) in the first three stages, meaning the judge thoroughly examines the legality, reality and causality of the reasons for termination, leaving little room for employer discretion.
In contrast, courts conduct a marginal review over proportionality. This allows more leeway for the employer in their decision-making, as the judge will in principle not second-guess the employer’s business decision or verify whether other business decisions might have been possible under the circumstances.
6. Is a reorganisation of the business (always) a valid reason for termination?
There is no doubt that a reorganisation of the business is linked to the operational requirements of the undertaking and can therefore in principle constitute a legitimate reason for termination.
To be acceptable, such reason must however also successfully complete the three other stages of the judicial review as outlined under Question no. 5 above.
First, the judge will conduct a strict verification of the reality of the (reason for the) reorganisation. For instance, an employer lost a case because the reorganisation was justified by a 7% decrease in the company’s turnover over the last two quarters compared to the same quarters of the preceding financial year, whereas a comparison based on a full financial year (which is the standard reference) showed a positive balance sheet (Labour Court of Liège, 5 October 2022).
Second, the employee’s dismissal must effectively be linked to the reorganisation. In a case before the Labour Appeal Court of Brussels, the employer was able to substantiate the economic difficulties in the context of the Covid pandemic. However, the employer failed to demonstrate the causal link between said difficulties and the employee’s dismissal. That is because other employees in a similar position were put on temporary unemployment and the overall headcount increased by the end of the year. As a result, the employer was ordered to pay damages corresponding to 8 weeks’ remuneration for patently unreasonable dismissal (Labour Appeal Court of Brussels, 10 June 2023).
Finally, if the reorganisation is sufficiently documented and the dismissal effectively linked to it, the choice of the employee(s) to be dismissed due to the reorganisation is subject to a marginal review by the court. As a result, it has been decided that it is not patently unreasonable for an employer to “give preference to experienced employees with a view to attracting new customers” (Labour Appeal Court of Brussels, 24 February 2020).
7. Is the employee’s sick leave a valid reason for termination?
Illness itself is a protected criteria under the anti-discrimination laws and can therefore not serve as a ground for dismissal, unless the absences due to illness form a legitimate and proportionate reason for termination.
Under CBA no. 109, such reason for termination will be subject to the same judicial review as outlined under Question no. 5 above.
Whether assessed under anti-discrimination laws or CBA no. 109, judges systematically require employers to demonstrate (i) the operational difficulties caused by employee’s (repeated and/or continued) sick leave (such as an increased workload for other employees, the need for frequent replacement or other temporary hires, disruptions in workflow, etc.) and (ii) that reasonable alternatives were taken or not available to remedy the employee’s absences.
Based on these principles, a dismissal was held patently unreasonable because the employer was unable to prove that the employee’s repeated absences could not be remedied by either the employee’s colleagues or external (temporary) workforce (Dutch Labour Court of Brussels, 20 February 2018). Conversely, the Labour Appeal Court of Brussels validated a dismissal based on the disruption to the business due to the employee’s repeated absences, because (i) the employee’s sick leave caused a higher workload for the other employees, and (ii) the employer had first taken remediation measures (i.e., a replacement contract) before deciding, after 8 months of continued absence of the employee and no sign of return to work any time soon, to hire a new employee under an open-ended contract (Labour Appeal Court of Brussels, 15 February 2022).
8. How is the amount of the indemnity for patently unreasonable dismissal determined?
If the dismissal is held to be patently unreasonable, the employee is entitled to an indemnity equal to between 3 and 17 weeks’ remuneration (including benefits, bonuses and incentives), on top of the termination payments.
The case-law and legal doctrine are far from uniform on the reasoning or criteria to be used to determine the amount of the indemnity within this range.
So far, courts however tend to order the employer to pay the maximum amount of the indemnity (i.e., 17 weeks), when:
the reasons for termination call the employee’s honesty or integrity into question (e.g., theft, lying, gross misconduct, etc.), but are not substantiated (Labour Court of Hainaut,19 May 2023 and Labour Court of Liège, 14 September 2022);
the reasons for termination are based on false or misleading information (Labour Court of Mons, 22 February 2021);
the decision to dismiss is taken in retaliation for legitimate behaviour on the part of the employee or with the intention to harm the employee’s reputation (Labour Appeal Court of Liège, 15 January 2019).
In contrast, the minimum amount is usually awarded to the employee when the reasons for termination are not sufficiently substantiated, but there are mitigating circumstances, such as wrong behaviour on the employee’s part or when the dismissal takes place in a context of tense or conflicting relations (Labour Court of Mons, 22 February 2021).
9. What is the limitation period for claims based on CBA no. 109?
In a landmark decision of 20 December 2021, the Belgian Court of Cassation held that claims based on CBA no. 109 must be brought before the labour courts within one (1) year after termination of the employment contract, thereby applying the ordinary limitation period for claims arising from the employment relationship.
10. How can Liedekerke assist you with claims based on CBA no. 109?
It is needless to emphasize that CBA no. 109 has significantly impacted dismissal practices in Belgium over the past 10 years.
Employers must remain vigilant in ensuring their dismissal decisions meet the standards set by CBA no. 109, as construed by the Belgian labour courts.
We assist on a daily basis employers in every step of the dismissal motivation process, for instance with:
assessing whether a reason could be considered as a valid reason for termination;
choosing the right wording for the reason(s) for termination on the C4-form;
drafting of dismissal motivation letters to respond to employees’ requests; and/or
challenging employees’ claims before the labour courts.
If you have any questions about CBA no. 109 or need assistance with a specific case, please do not hesitate to reach out to our Employment & Benefits team.