Belgian Data Protection Authority considers complaint regarding the transfer of personal data to local police department in a football context
Category: IP/IT/Data
Key takeaways
The data minimisation principle implies that personal data about an employee should not be shared to his employer by a third party when the employer does not need to have access to the data. The shared data should not include the employee’s favourite football club or other information, when the data sharing concerns the annulment of the employee’s ticket to a game because he supports a rival club.
Football clubs (and sport clubs in general) should be clearly aware of their legal obligations and whether personal data processing is necessary to comply with these obligations. Legislation in a football context needs to directly include an obligation to process personal data (including sharing it with law enforcement); when alternatives are available, data processing is not considered necessary.
When personal data is shared with law enforcement due to a task of public interest (e.g. ensuring safety of game spectators), the data can only be shared if this task is sufficiently specific and requires personal data to be shared. Sport clubs should ensure that data sharing is a ‘must have’ and not a ‘nice to have’.
A football club in the Belgian second division organised an event, as a part of which employees of its main sponsor could receive tickets to attend a football game. The complainant was an employee of the main sponsor who received a message that his ticket was cancelled and that he would not be able to attend the game, because he was registered as a supporter of a rival club. The employee’s personal data was shared to his employer (i.e. the main sponsor) by the football club.
When the employee requested information as to how the football club received the information about the club he supports, the club stated that this information was obtained because of a police audit. The football club argued that, under Belgian football law, it had to transfer a list of issued entry tickets to the police for high-risk games to avoid rival supporters being seated with the club’s own supporters. This transfer included the full name and date of birth of the persons who have an entry ticket.
After being informed, the employee filed a complaint based on the alleged unlawful transfer of his personal data to the police. The Belgian Data Protection Authority (BDPA) issued its Decision on 27 January 2026. In the decision, two data transfers are evaluated: the transfer by the club to the employer and the transfer by the club to the local police. However, the discussion of the decision goes beyond its scope.
I. Application of the data minimisation principle
With regard to the transfer by the club to the employer, the BDPA highlights the principle of data minimisation enshrined in article 5.1.c GDPR, according to which only personal data necessary and relevant for the envisioned purpose should be processed. In line with recital 39 GDPR, personal data can only be processed when the purpose cannot be reasonably fulfilled through other means.
The BDPA decides that the football club “threatens to breach” the data minimisation principle by sharing personal data of the employee to his employer outside of the processing purpose. The specific reason why the employee could not attend the match (i.e. supporting a rival club) should not have been shared. The BDPA states that it would have sufficed to inform the employee himself and not the employer. This does not seem to coincide with the purpose of the processing, i.e. ‘informing the employer that its employee cannot attend the event’.
II. Legal ground for processing and transferring the personal data
The second evaluation concerned the transfer by the club to the local police of the employee’s personal data. First, the BDPA reminds us that only one legal basis under article 6.1 GDPR can be relied upon for each processing activity; it is not allowed to proverbially throw legal grounds at the wall and see which one sticks. It was not possible for the football club to state both the legal ground of processing to perform a task of public interest and the legal ground of processing to comply with a legal obligation.
The football club argued that it could process the personal data based on article 10, §1, 4° of the law concerning security at football games of 21 December 1998. This article states, paraphrased, that organisers of a football game must implement security measures aimed at securing spectators of the game and public services, by managing spectators’ movements or separating rivalling fans. However, the article was not deemed a sufficiently specific legal obligation by the BDPA for football clubs to process personal data, because a margin of interpretation remains for its application (i.e. regarding the security measures to be implemented).
Second, moving to the other possible legal ground, the BDPA acknowledged that ensuring security at football matches is a valid task carried out in the public interest. However, it remains unclear to what extent processing personal data is part of carrying out that task, as the legal text does not specify anything in that regard. Even though the BDPA admits that legal texts describing tasks in the public interest are often not written in a specific way (to allow for a certain margin of interpretation), it is up to the data controller to determine whether the data processing is necessary and proportionate in such situations. In this case, transferring any personal data to the police was not deemed necessary and proportionate for the purpose of separating rivalling fans to ensure security of spectators and public services during a football game. By referring to case law of the EU Court of Justice, the BDPA argues that less intrusive measures were available to achieve the same purpose. Put differently, the football club should have ensured security during the football game (by separating rival fans) via another method than simply transferring ticketholders’ personal data to the police.
The BDPA gave a warning to the football club for both (potential) infringements. In the remainder of this insight, some difficulties and the practical impact of the decision are discussed.
III. Legal obligations in the football context
Although the BDPA briefly states the possible application of other legal obligations for the football club, these are not further discussed in the decision. Indeed, other legal obligations could justify the collection and transfer to the police of personal data in a similar context as this case (see nr. 27), such as articles 12 and 13 of the Royal Decree of 20 July 2005. In short, these articles hold that football clubs should be able to permanently provide an overview of all distributed entry tickets and season tickets, which must include the full name and date of birth of the persons involved. The police officers authorized to enforce the law (on security during football games) and its executive decisions have access “at all times” to the data collected under the scope of the Royal Decree.
In other words, the football club could rely on the legal ground ‘compliance with a legal obligation’ in article 6.1.c GDPR, both for the processing of personal data (i.e. full name and date of birth) and for the transfer of said personal data to the local police. Other legal obligations can be equally relevant, on the condition that these obligations are specific enough to require personal data processing. For example, in the context of stadium bans it is possible for the police to share pictures of persons who have received such ban to certain persons at the football club (articles 43bis and 45 of the Act on safety during football games). Had the football club provided these legal obligations, the decision may have had a different outcome.
IV. Data transfers between football clubs and the police and ‘necessity’
A second question is why the data on a person’s favourite club was collected by the police and subsequently shared with the football clubs. It should be noted that this is not fully clear in the decision; it is stated that the club obtained this data “as a result of a police audit”. Considering the approach by the BDPA in this decision, it seems that such transfer should only happen if it is necessary and proportional to comply with a legal obligation under football legislation, or to perform a well-defined task of public interest. For example, definitely for the purpose of enforcing stadium-bans, the data transfer is necessary because the club needs to identify the specific persons who are banned.
In this regard, it is interesting to note that the Royal Decree of 20 July 2005 was amended based on the advice of the BDPA in 2020. The BDPA had recommended to clearly state the purposes regarding the obliged ‘overview of distributed entry tickets and season tickets’ where personal data is included, these purposes being limited to (i) verifying whether the distributed tickets do not exceed the capacity of the stadium and (ii) verifying whether no tickets were sold to persons with a stadium-ban (see advice nr. 15). Both purposes were ultimately specified in the Royal Decree. The former purpose does not seem to require personal data processing, whereas the latter – as noted – does. Considering the data minimisation principle, the processing should in any case be limited to what is strictly necessary to achieve the purpose. It is doubtful whether sharing a person’s favourite club would be necessary for these purposes.
Regarding tasks of public interest, the BDPA states that based on executive decisions and guidance by policymakers, it can find no reason why processing of personal data should take place to achieve the purpose of “separating rival fans” (i.e. part of the public interest of ensuring safety during football games). This reasoning is commendable from a privacy perspective, but may be difficult to meaningfully enforce in practice. Assessing when data processing is necessary for these purposes remains a grey area in practice, even when considering the examples given by the Ministerial Circular of 21 February 2006 (such as “certain physical characteristics” or “certain behaviours” or “when in doubt, asking the fan who he supports”). The interpretation by the BDPA that the law is “aimed more at separating groups of rivalling fans, rather than singling out individual fans” makes sense, considering the overarching purpose of ensuring security during a game. However, it may still be difficult to meaningfully succeed in separating rival fans solely via methods where no personal data is processed, or to draw the line as to when a number of rivalling fans is considered a ‘group’. Security can be threatened by select individuals as well.
In sum, there may be a thin line in practice between whether and when personal data processing is considered ‘necessary’ for different purposes in the football context, regardless of whether the processing is based on a legal obligation or on the performance of a task in the public interest. This assessment is however crucial when determining the correct legal ground under the GDPR.