Back to home

Reform of the Social Criminal Code

Category: Employment & Benefits

On 26 March 2024, a draft bill containing amendments to the social criminal law was submitted by the Government in the Parliament. On 8 May 2024 the bill was adopted in a plenary session of the Parliament. The text was published in the Belgian Official Gazette on 21 June 2024. The amendments entered into force on 1 July 2024.

I. BACKGROUND

The purpose of the draft bill is to supplement and amend the Social Criminal Code of 6 June 2010 (Belgian Official Gazette 1 July 2010) (hereafter: the Code) and various provisions of social criminal law. For the purposes of this newsletter, only the amendments of the Code are addressed.

The reform of the Code is the result of several exercises: an evaluation after more than 10 years of application in the field, the endeavour to only provide for imprisonment as a sanction when there is no alternative and, by extension, the examination of further possibilities of depenalisation, the alignment of the Code with the most recent evolutions within the framework of the revision of the Criminal Code and the Code of Criminal Procedure and, finally, the alignment of the sanction levels for similar infringements in the general and social criminal law.

The amendments concern both the provisions of Book 1 of the Code, relating to the prevention, detection and criminal prosecution of infringements and the sanction levels as well as the infringements in Book 2 of the Code

Only the most important amendments, and thus not all amendments, are discussed below.

II. AMENDMENTS OF BOOK 1

II. 1. Amendments of the sanctions

Article 101 of the Code, providing the four sanction levels, is amended. The aim of the amendment is to strengthen the role of criminal fines and administrative fines and limit imprisonment to the most serious cases only. The four sanction levels are retained, but the fines for sanction level 3 are doubled. In addition, the maximum fines for level 4 sanctions have been increased.

The table below shows the sanction levels and sanctions applicable before and after the amendment.

Sanction level

Administrative fine

Criminal fine

Imprisonment

Before

After

Before

After

Before

After

Level 1

EUR 10 - 100

EUR 10 - 100

/

/

/

/

Level 2

EUR 25 - 250

EUR 25 - 250

EUR 50 - 500

EUR 50 - 500

/

/

Level 3

EUR 50 - 500

EUR 100 - 1.000

EUR 100 - 1.000

EUR 200 - 2.000

/

/

Level4

EUR 300 - 3.000

EUR 300 - 3.500

EUR 600 - 6.000

EUR 600 - 7.000

6m - 3y

6m - 3y

The above amounts of the fines still need to be increased with a surcharge (opdeciemen/décimes additionnels), which currently amounts to multiplying by 8. In addition, for each type of infringement, consideration should be given to whether the fine might be multiplied by the number of employees involved (with a maximum of 100).

Finally, the addition of a fifth sanction level was considered, but was deleted following the advice from the National Labour Council (Nationale Arbeidsraad/Conseil National du Travail).

II. 2. Exclusion from the right to tender for public contracts or to obtain concessions    

A new Article 107/1 is introduced in the Code that contains a new special sanction.

For level 3 and 4 infringements, in addition to the operating ban, the prohibition of activities and the business closure (Articles 106 and 107 Code), the court can now impose the exclusion from the right to tender for public contracts or to obtain concessions.

This exclusion can be imposed for a period of three years to a maximum of five years.

Contrary to the sanctions in Articles 106 and 107, which are optional sanctions that can be imposed by the courts if a level 3 or 4 sanction is imposed and if the article in the Code that contains the infringement in question specifically allows for this possibility, the new sanction in Article 107/1 can be imposed by the courts if any level 3 or 4 sanction is imposed except in circumstances provided for by law.

II. 3. Intentional fraud as an aggravating factor

New Articles 110/1 and 115/1 are introduced in the Code that introduce an aggravating factor. Previously, the Code only contained mitigating circumstances (Article 110 Code).

If level 4 infringements are committed intentionally, the court must consider this as an aggravating factor when deciding which sanction to impose under the level 4 sanctions and when deciding whether to impose additional special sanctions (the operating ban, the prohibition of activities, the business closure and the (new) exclusion from the right to tender for public contracts or to obtain concessions).

II. 4. Repetition    

Articles 108 and 111 of the Code are amended. Previously, these articles stipulated that in case of repetition within the year following a conviction, an administrative or judicial decision of guilt or a decision imposing an administrative or criminal fine, the amount of the administrative or criminal fine may be increased to twice the maximum.

This one-year period is now extended to a three-year period. This will likely cause a repetition to occur more often within the meaning of the Code.

III. Amendments of book 2

III. 1. Sanction levels of certain infringements

The sanction levels of certain infringements are amended to maintain consistency between the applicable sanctions for infringements of the same type and gravity. Both increases as well as decreases in sanction levels are implemented.

Some examples of the infringements for which the sanction levels have been increased:

  • infringements relating to the payment of salaries to employees will henceforth be sanctioned with a level 3 sanction instead of a level 2 sanction (Article 162 Code);

  • infringements relating to the payment of various contributions to the National Social Security Office (Rijksdienst voor Sociale Zekerheid/Office Nationale de Sécurité Sociale) or to other institutions or social security funds (Fonds voor bestaanszekerheid/Fonds de sécurité d'existence) will henceforth be sanctioned with a level 3 sanction instead of a level 2 sanction (Articles 218, 219 and 220 Code);

  • infringements relating to the notification and information disclosure in case of collective lay-off will henceforth be sanctioned with a level 3 sanction instead of a level 2 sanction (Article 193 Code);

  • infringements relating to the obstruction of the Social Inspectorate (Article 209 Code):

    o   the multiplication of the fine by the number of employees involved is retained but is henceforth optional and no longer mandatory as it is not always possible to know the correct number of employees; and

    o   the use of physical or psychological violence against a social inspector or threatening a social inspector will henceforth become an aggravating factor to be considered by the court.

Some examples of the infringements for which the sanction levels have been decreased:

  • some infringements relating to the part-time employees (e.g. not keeping a copy of the employment contract at the location where the company work rules can be consulted) will henceforth be sanctioned with a level 2 sanction instead of a level 3 sanction (Article 151 Code); and

  • infringements relating to the announcement of replacement days of public holidays will henceforth be sanctioned with a level 1 sanction instead of a level 2 sanction (Article 143 Code).

The above lists are not exhaustive.

III. 2. New infringements    

Finally, new infringements are added to the Code concerning, for example:

  • failure to comply with the obligations for the application of floating work schedules, sanctioned with a level 2 sanction (Article 146/1 Code);

  • failure to grant eco vouchers that are due, or the delayed granting of eco vouchers, sanctioned with a level 2 sanction (Article 166/1 Code);

  • failure to provide financial compensation for the supply, maintenance and cleaning of work clothes, sanctioned with a level 2 sanction (Article 166/2 Code); and

  • failure to comply with the obligations concerning holiday certificates, sanctioned with a level 2 sanction (Article 188/5 Code).

This list is not exhaustive.

 ***

Our Employment & Benefits team would be delighted to address any queries you may have in relation to the reform of the Social Criminal Code.

Back to overview